They soon joined other Scotch Irish immigranats in western Pennsylvania, where land was still easily available for the clearing. Records show that John, William, and Andrew signed on with local militias as soon as they were old enough to do so. John, Andrew, and William made formal petition to become American citizens by renouncing all allegiance to the King of Great Britain in 1824 and 1825. By some odd quirk of historical preservation, I have those papers.
It did not take the McCaskey sons long to scatter. A letter dated 9 Nov, 1826, came from Smithfield Township in Jefferson County, Ohio. William McCaskey informed his mother, Jane McCaskey, that he was working on the turnpike in Ohio and suggested that his brothers John and Joseph could make a lot of money if they wanted to join him the following spring. Now that weather had halted roadwork for the winter, he was working as a stonecutter. He reported that brother James has been visiting since October and had been ill, although he was getting better after taking medicine from an Indian doctor. James was apparently a traveling salesmen, purchasing goods in Pittsburgh and then selling then in the countryside.
Two of the daughters also traveled on to Ohio with their American husbands. A May 30, 1833 letter arrived from Conneaut, Ohio. Allen Law wrote to his brother-in-law John McCaskey to tell him that he and his wife Nancy McCaskey were in tolerably good health but would like to return to Pennsylvania. He wanted the McCaskeys to be on the lookout for a piece of land in their area. He was willing to pay $600 down, followed by $200 in April, and then $100 a year for the next three or four years. I have no further evidence about that family, except for a strange 1838 local newspaper with the name Allen Law written at the bottom.
On Aug. 25, 1835, John Dullaghan, Jr. sent worse news from Wooster, Ohio. He reports that his father had died on Aug. 3rd of consumption. Junior himself has had fever that settled in his knees, and his mother, Jane McCaskey, had been unable to use her arms for two months. Nevertheless, they planned to pay a visit to the Pennsylvania family in the next month or two if they could get their old wagon repaired. I've had a bit of correspondence from a possible cousin showing that the family name of John Dullaghan continued to be passed down from generation to generation, but there are unexplained gaps in our genealogical data.
The onlyother one of the McCaskey children I can trace further is John Jr., who is my great-grandfather, and he's the one whose very grave has disappeared.